Colloquia


The Eighth Annual Colloquium on Environmental Law & Institutions

Reconstructing Climate Policy:
Moving Beyond the Kyoto Impasse

Duke University
Durham, NC
May 11 and 12, 2003

Thirty-eight experts from academia, business, and non-governmental organizations participated in the recent two-day colloquium "Reconstructing Climate Policy: Moving Beyond the Kyoto Impasse." With the ambitious objectives of identifying creative new options for climate change policy, considering the means for interdisciplinary design of incentives in public policy, and determining research needs for future climate policy development, the attendees participated in eight sessions on critical issues. (more)

Co-Sponsored by
The Micro-Incentives Research Center (MIRC),
Duke Center for Environmental Solutions (CES), and The Center on Global Change

Agenda | Publications | Participant Biographies | Event Photos

Conference Objectives

  • - Develop and discuss creative new options for climate change policy
  • - Foster interdisciplinary interaction among sciences, social sciences, policy, and law, regarding a major use of incentives in public policy
  • - Identify key research needs (in science, social science, policy, and law) for future climate policy development

Back to Top


Agenda

Sunday, May 11, 2003
 
8:00pm
Pre-Conference Dinner
Monday, May 12, 2003
 
Rhodes Conference Room, Sanford Institute of Public Policy, Duke University
 
8:15am
Continental Breakfast
 
8:30am
Welcomes
 
Peter Lange, Provost, Duke University
 
William Schlesinger, Dean, Nicholas School of the Environment and Earth Sciences, Duke University
 
Bruce Jentleson, Director, Sanford Institute of Public Policy,
Duke University
 
Michael Munger, Director, MIRC, and Chair, Department of Political Science, Duke University
 
8:45am
Opening Remarks: "Reconstructing Climate Policy: Beyond Kyoto"
 
This session will outline the analysis in the new book by Richard B. Stewart & Jonathan B. Wiener, Reconstructing Climate Policy: Beyond Kyoto (American Enterprise Press, 2003). The book evaluates the Kyoto Protocol and potential next steps (such as the US joining Kyoto now, the US staying out of Kyoto indefinitely, and other alternatives such as international emissions taxes). It proposes a new climate treaty regime led by the U.S. and China, operating in parallel to Kyoto with the possibility of eventual merger, using international emissions trading both to reduce costs and to engage participation
 
Chair:
Jonathan Wiener, Duke University School of Law, Nicholas School of the Environment and Earth Sciences, Faculty Director, Center for Environmental Solutions
 
Keynote Speaker: Richard Stewart, University Professor, New York University
 
9:30am
Forecasting Climate Change Impacts: Globally and on Key Regional Actors
 
This session will focus on the potential benefits of forestalling future climate change (avoided climate damages), both globally and for major emitting countries such as the United States and China. How do expected national climate change impacts influence the treaty negotiations over emissions limitations? Might China and the US be reluctant to reduce emissions in part because they perceive modest losses, or even gains, due to global warming? What new research is needed to improve global and regional-scale forecasts of climate change impacts?
 
Chair:
James Clark, Center on Global Change and Nicholas School of the Environment & Earth Sciences, Duke University
 
Speaker:
Roni Avissar, Pratt School of Engineering, Duke University
 
Discussant:
Gabi Hegerl, Nicholas School of the Environment & Earth Sciences, Duke University
 
10:45am
Break
 
11:00am
Optimizing Climate Policy Over Time
 
This session will address the "targets and timetables" for emissions limitations in the Kyoto Protocol, development of alternative time paths for emissions limitations, and the challenge of adaptive learning and updating of policy choices over time.
 
Chair:
Lynn Maguire, Nicholas School of the Environment & Earth Sciences,
Duke University
 
Speakers:
James Hammitt, Center for Risk Analysis, Harvard School of Public Health
Mort Webster, Department of Public Policy, University of North Carolina
 
Discussant:
V. Kerry Smith, Department of Agricultural Economics,
North Carolina State University
 
12:15pm
Lunch
 
1:30pm
Emissions Trading, Costs, and Participation
 
This session will examine the use of greenhouse gas emissions trading (compared to alternatives such as emissions taxes) to reduce the costs of abatement and, via the allocation of allowances to otherwise reluctant participants, to engage participation by industry and by developing countries. It will also discuss the implications of accession to the Kyoto Protocol emissions trading regime by the US alone, by China alone, or the proposed development of a U.S.-China parallel regime that leads to accession by the US and China jointly to a reformed Kyoto regime.
 
Chair:
Barbara Braatz, Center on Global Change, Duke University
 
Speakers:
Richard Richels, Electric Power Research Institute
John Reilly, Joint Program on the Science & Policy of Global Change, MIT
 

Discussant:

Richard Rosenzweig, Managing Director, Natsource
 

3:00pm

Break
 
3:15pm
Engaging China and other Major Emitting Developing Countries
 
This session will examine the net benefits to China and other major developing countries of participation in a global climate regime, including the regional impacts of global warming on China, the co-benefits to China of reduction of other pollutants, and whether emissions trading and allocation of "headroom" allowances could engage participation by China and other developing countries. Why do China and other developing countries oppose international emissions trading when the economic models show them to be major winners from such a system? What are China's strategy and politics on this issue?
 
Chair:
Robert Keohane, Department of Political Science, Nicholas School and Law School, Duke University
 
Speakers:
ZhongXiang Zhang, East-West Center
Daniel Dudek, Senior Economist, Environmental Defense
 
Discussants:
Richard Morgenstern, Resources for the Future
Jonathan Ocko, Department of History, North Carolina State University & Duke Law School
 
4:45pm
Break
 
5:00pm
Next Steps: The Prospects for Reconstructing Climate Policy
 
This session will invite open group discussion on key questions. Which policy options seem most desirable, and which ones might actually be pursued in the policy arena? Which options deserve additional attention and research? What kinds of further research and new information would be most useful in constructing sensible and successful climate policy?
 
Chair:
Michael Munger, Duke
 
Open group discussion
 
Jonathan Wiener, Duke
Richard Stewart, NYU
 
6:00pm
Reception - Burdman Lounge, Duke University School of Law
 
Welcome by Katharine Bartlett, Dean, Duke University School of Law
 
Drinks & Light hors d'oeuvres
 
7:00pm
Dinner

Publications

*Colloquium participants have provided links to various related papers.

Joseph E. Aldy, Scott Barrett & Robert N. Stavins, Thirteen Plus One: A Comparison of Global Climate Policy Architectures

Roni Avissar & W.H. Gardner, Regional Teleconnections and their Global Hydroclimatological Effects: The Land Use / Land-Cover Change Example

Daniel Dudek, SO2 Emissions Trading in China

James K. Hammitt, Evaluation Endpoints and Climate Policy: Atmospheric Stabilization and Benefit-Cost Analysis, and Near-Term Greenhouse Gas Emissions

James K. Hammitt, Global Climate Change: Benefit-Cost Analysis vs. The Precautionary Principle

Brian C. O’Neill and Michael Oppenheimer, Dangerous Climate Impacts and the Kyoto Protocol

John Reilly, Complexities in International Trade of Greenhouse Gas Emissions Permits—And International Architecture without Trading

Rich Rosenzweig, The Evolving International Greenhouse Gas Emissions Trading Market

Richard B. Stewart & Jonathan B. Wiener, Reconstructing Climate Policy: Beyond Kyoto (American Enterprise Institute Press, 2003)

Richard Richels, Emission Trading, Costs, and Participation

Mort Webster, Incorporating Path-Dependency into Decision Analytic Methods: An Application to Global Climate Change Policy

ZhongXiang Zhang, Reconstructing Climate Policy: How Best to Engage China and Other Developing Countries?

ZhongXiang Zhang, Meeting the Kyoto Targets: The Importance of Developing Country Participation

Back to Top | Agenda | Publications | Participant Biographies


last updated: October 17, 2003